Man of Steel #5 review

Last issue ended with Superman unleashing his flare power, the entirety of his stored yellow sun energy, in a bid to bring down Rogol Zaar. Which meant this issue would see him powerless for 24 hours, until his body had absorbed enough solar rays to power him up again.

This issue opens with Superman dragging the creature who claims to have murdered Krypton into space, to battle him away from his adopted world.

I’m not sure how that works. The solar burst business is relatively new to the Superman canon, having debuted with Supergirl in the New 52 period and been adopted by the Superman title shortly afterwards. It seemed to have been forgotten, but there it was in Man of Steel #4, a drastic play by a desperate hero.

We know from the Meanwhiles of this issue that we’ve not had a day between chapters, the opening follows directly on from #4, suggesting writer Brian Michael Bendis is ignoring the most interesting aspect of the solar flare. There’s something else he looks to be whistling merrily out of continuity this time, but I’ll get to that.

Short recap. Superman and Rogol Zaar fight above the Earth and Kal-El is beaten into the lunar surface. Down below, Metropolis fire chief Melody Moore tries to see a pattern in the arson attacks on the city, and Supergirl helps out with the latest blaze.

The Justice League arrives to help and Kara works out where her missing cousin likely is.

The moon. Supergirl takes Superman back to the League’s new Hall of Justice HQ, where he soon wakes, and realises what Rogol Zaar’s next move is.

That’s the present day story in Man of Steel #5, but we also get four pages continuing the flashback which has seen Jor-El appear in the Kent apartment and ask to be entrusted with his grandson, Jon. We see what he wants…… but not what he gets. I suspect Superman doesn’t stand in the way of Jon going, and Lois insists on accompanying her son and Jor-El. After all, would you want your kid, however super, going off into space with a literal relative stranger who ran a global terror organisation, when he wasn’t kidnapping superheroes, villains and Mr Mxyzptlk.

None of which is mentioned in the four page scene; yes, Lois and Clark say ‘a hard no’ but you’d think they would verbalise their reasons. And it’s not like Jon doesn’t know his paternal grandfather is, to be kind, deeply disturbed. But that’s all glossed over and while it may come up next time, this is the logical moment. Has Bendis removed it from continuity. God knows, I’d like the entire Mr Oz arc erased, but you can’t do that while still having a scarred, oddly coiffed version of Jor-El alive.

My other problem with this issue, beyond the Jor-El and solar flare business, is that Rogol Zara’s entire motivation is to kill Kryptonians. He has Superman near unconscious on the moon, he swings his axe… and doesn’t decapitate him.

A more minor moan, but something that irked me, is how Bendis writes the Flash. Like a lunatic man-child. Is he going for the version seen on the big screen? If so, why? That guy’s an idiot teenager, the comics Barry Allen never has been, and never should be, an immature prat.

There were things I liked in the script: the arrival of Supergirl is pure delight, the understated reverse homage to Crisis on Infinite Earths #7 is cute, the fire house scene was nicely done, and Flash apart, the League scenes were great. There’s something STAR Labs has advised Superman not to do that makes good sense, and Bendis continues to show the warmth between the Kryptonian cousins with real skill.

He’s aided enormously by the nuanced art of Adam Hughes, who illustrates the bulk of the issue – the Jor-El scene belongs to the excellent Jason Fabok – in full colour. And it is glorious, with standout visuals including the Metropolis fire, with Green Lantern’s ring glowing against the burnt oranges, the mayhem on the moon and a climactic spread I won’t spoil. Little details like Superman’s cape draped over the hospital bed are lovely. The most impressive moment of synergy between writer and artist is the opening splash page, with Superman pondering the fate of the Kandorians, as Rogol Zaar eyed their bottle city.


The cover is a look back to the Death of Superman – well done by penciller Ivan Reis, inker Joe Prado and colourist Alex Sinclair, who handles the interior Jor-El sequence, but it’s an image we’ve seen so many times… I’d rather see something from this issue, something new.

Despite the problems I had this time, I’m still enjoying this mini-series, and looking forward to next issue’s wrap. This being a Brian Bendis story, I’m not convinced we’ll actually get clarification of the various mysteries, but I live in hope. At the very least, more neat nuggets of characterisation, and outstanding art, is guaranteed.

8 thoughts on “Man of Steel #5 review

  1. Argh, yes, that Barry dialogue! Snyder has been making him jokier, too — at least since Metal — and I don’t think that’s a bad thing to do, to give him an irreverent sense of humor. It’s a personality trait other than “stolid,” and I’m all for that. (And I do think a quick wit befits the guy.) But “caca poo poo”? I just don’t buy it. Maybe I’d buy it if it were a little bit funny. But it’s basically dialogue from the Ronnie Raymond Firestorm days.

    As for Jor-El, I don’t think he’s been retconned at all since the last we saw him. I think them not talking about their last encounter is simply Bendis’s preference for not having characters say what they all already know. For a guy who has a reputation for over-writing, in some ways he’s a minimalist. It might come up next issue, though.

    As for why RZ didn’t behead him. I don’t know. Wonder Woman offers an explanation, but I don’t buy it either.

    I’ll have to reread issue 4 to see about that Solar Flare power. When I’d read that issue, the solar flare didn’t occur to me; I wasn’t quite sure what happened in that last scene. So Superman having powers at the top of this issue didn’t bug me.

    But man, Bendis, show Barry some respect!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Certainly Superman, on the penultimate page of last issue, seems to be sucking in, girding himself to exhale all that solar energy. Let me know what you think, if you have time.


  2. Yeah, looking at it again, you might be right. I just assumed he’d lit up something explosive in the Fortress.

    Also, who do you think he was trying to call at the end of issue 4? Jon or Jor-El, I guess? No one else is coming to mind.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. As usual we picked the same images to focus.

    I can’t get past the Lois/Jon scene. There is no way a parent would let their kid go off with a maniac like Oz. And we have read Jon stories for a couple of year’s now. He loves and worships his father. He mourned leaving Hamilton. He wouldn’t want to leave the Earth behind. Makes no sense unless it is a feint by Jon to get close to the enemy.

    I also have a hard time with how often Zaar, who has traveled the universe to cleanse it of Kryptonians, has left a battered Superman alive when he could kill him.

    These two things pull down some nice moments with Kara and the League.

    This is the first issue I have been disappointed with.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I get you, Anj. ‘What the…?’ moments really do pull a person out of the story. Why would Superman even do his loony dad the courtesy of listening? He’s insane, and dangerous, and shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near Jon and Lois.


  4. I really loved this, and I think Zaar wants Superman to see Earth die.

    The one thing I loved most, however, was the Supergirl scenes. Since the New 52, with a few exceptions, these two have been painted as barely knowing each other. I love that Bendis is bringing back a closer bond between the two. For Kara, it has to feel special to have one person who is Kryptonian like her to talk to, and the fact that they are family makes it even more special a connection. I’m really happy that DC has turned away from the whole Raging Kara thing.

    I am sure Lois went with Jon, but I still have to wonder about Jor-El. Is he really Superman’s father, or is he from a different universe. Lots of funny things have been happening to the multiverse since Convergence, so maybe he’s one of those quirks, a man who suddenly found himself in another universe, not realizing it. If DR Manhattan pulled him out of the exploding Krypton, it could have been any Krypton, not just this one.

    I love the new site.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Hector. I like the idea that this is an alternate Jor-El. My Jor-El will always be the Silver and Bronze Age guy, and the more a Jor-El skews towards that version, the happier I am. Same deal with Lara – that woman is OBSESSED with yellow frocks!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.