Superman #43 review

The Man of Steel is back – and so is the Daily Planet. For the first time in years, the Metropolis newshounds star in an issue of Superman.

There’s Cat Grant, gossip columnist turned crime reporter, pounding the streets with ghostly fighter for justice Marilyn Moonlight and coming across a graveyard that should not be there.

Lois Lane, still a bad fit for the Daily Planet editorship – she should be on the streets uncovering secrets and lies – but working hard to do a good job.

And Jimmy Olsen, assigned to help Clark dig into the mystery of missing Metropolitans.

This is what I want – a sense that Clark and co are actual journalists, intimately tied to their city, in tune with its heartbeat. And that’s what writer Joshua Williamson and artist Xermanico give us in a superbly paced and structured story, showing us day – and more dramatically, night – in Metropolis.

The issue opens with Cat recording as she seeks Marilyn Moonlight, the ghost from Western days who protects citizens. She’s only recently revealed herself to Superman, so I’m impressed she’s letting Cat report on her activities. And I’m delighted to see Marilyn has a spooky riddle to solve, one that quickly pulls in Clark after he notices, a few days down the line, Cat has gone missing. It’s heartening to see how much Clark cares about Cat, as he recaps her history, his heart breaking over the most tragic aspect. His thoughts are, as they say, rudely interrupted.

And we do meet – or at least hear about – the resurrection cult’s master, who’s a very big player in the DC Hall of Infamy. And given Clark’s mention of the murder of Cat’s little boy, Adam, I wonder if he’ll be dragged into a resurrection plot – I do hope not.

We also get a one-page cameo from one of my favourite DC menaces, something whose jolly features belie its casually murderous nature – Chemo.

Another highlight is bar owner Bibbo’s interaction with Clark and Jimmy, and the red-headed reporter defending Clark after Bibbo disparages him.

As if the story wasn’t enough to make me happy, we have the debut of new series artist Xermanico, who was born to draw these characters. Everyone is totally on model, while looking extra fresh. And the layouts are eye-catching without calling too much attention to themselves, but when I do notice the occasional flourish, I smile. One favourite is a series of panels shaped to evoke rays of sunshine as Superman is appreciating the dawn.

And while showy moments such as the Man of Steel meeting those hideous monsters look amazing, quieter details, such as the decor in Lois’ corner office, also dazzle. Xermanico has been drawing at DC for a while and it’s great to see him get a top assignment, and grabbing the opportunity by the cape.

The illustrations are brought to a new level by longtime series colour artist Alejandro Sanchez, whose dead of night is as eye-popping as his dawn of day. Dig that mist!

And regular letterer Ariana Maher is also on top form, with clever ways to add mood to written dialogue – new for this issue, tiny Daily Planet globes.

Add in Xermanico’s stunning cover and we have the perfect jumping-on point for anyone who hasn’t been reading this series. In a year that’s seen an awful lot of great issues, Superman #43 is a new peak.

11 thoughts on “Superman #43 review”

  1. I did enjoy this. I’m curious about Marilyn Midnight but not enough to get back issues. I hate with a passion stories with children killed and Cat’s is in the top three of those. Her getting her son back with no bad side to it would be great.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. DC should quiz any writer who wants her in the supporting cast on the regular if they were reading when the kid was killed. That’s how stuff comes back.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I haven’t read this yet, but I’m glad to hear that Cat Grant is apparently being written & drawn much more like her old self, and not as the bitter shrew who dressed up like a trashy cougar that we got a while back. And it’s always good when the Superman books remember that they have a rich supporting cast that they can draw upon. So, maybe I’ll pick this one up.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Between this issue and the Wedding Special, it almost feels like Metropolis is a priority in the Superman books again. And look, I get it: The last year and change of stories had to take place outside the boroughs, but I’m so glad we are back to the equivalent of “Street Level” Superman.

    Obviously the cult leader is evil, but he does have a point about normal people never getting their loved ones returned after Crises.

    I concur with your enjoyment of the art. I smiled at several parts, particularly Bibbo’s Space Zombies.

    I do have one small quibble, though. It is a little disappointing that we have two Superman books coming out the same week with scenes in Lois’s office, and they don’t even closely resemble each other. I know artistic licensing and all that, but I wish they disseminated some basic schematics of key locations (Daily Planet, LexCorp Building, Steelworks, Fortress of Solitude, the Kent Farm, & the Kent-Lane Apartment).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Lois moved offices in between. Yeah, that’s it. Whenever I see a corner office I always think of Law & Order – anyone with a swanky corner base is EVIL.

      More Metropolis would be such a boon, all superheroes all the time is dull.

      Like

  4. Great review!

    For sure Cat is being lured into this cult with the promise of her son coming back. I just hope it doesn’t happen. For sure he’ll be a zombie.

    I think it is the perfect time for a horror story after the more recent big sci-fi arcs. And with Superman having Omega energy, saving the universe, saving the planet I actually like seeing him weakened at the end of the issue. We need some stakes …

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Oh heck, I really do not want an Adam Grant zombie, he was a nice kid and Cat would never recover.

      It is rather exciting to see Superman in that state, it’s been a while.

      Like

  5. I never like seeing Superman being weakened, which is why the “street level” stories tend to not be for me. If you can’t tell the story with a powerful Superman (see All-Star Superman if you don’t know how), you’re fired. What’s more, if the hit is doing this to him, I hope he’ll be going to the Fortress of Solitude and access the Kryptonian tech there to sort things out. . .and that won’t happen. He’ll either suffer or go to STAR labs, some rut like that. Still, despite my own personal criticisms, it was a good story overall, with top artwork. . .rendered with a great review as always!

    Like

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.