DC All In Special #1 review

Flip books. How I hate them. You’re reading a comic and you get to the middle and have to turn it upside down, usually for no good reason. It’s just a gimmick. DC All In Special does have a decent excuse for the chapters starting from opposite ends of the book, meeting in the middle and flipping. And it’s still blooming irritating.

I mean, don’t DC remember they sell these things not just in paper, but digitally? And while I can turn my tablet upside down – get that rotation lock on, kids – and get an idea of the desired effect, what are people who read on desktops meant to do?

So what is it that narratively justifies a flip book?

The story on the A-side, ‘Alpha’, sees heroes invited to sign up for Justice League Unlimited, a reaction to Amanda Waller’s war on heroes – the story takes place 52 days after Absolute Power #4.

Soon, the big day arrives and heroes who have accepted the offer – it seems that, like, Robotman, Metamorpho says no – are addressed by Mr Terrific.

Within seconds, an alarm sounds, and things get crazy.

Who’s ripping through reality?

Darkseid is.

As for how he got there, the ‘Alpha’ underside of the comic reveals all.

The dark god of Apokolips is trying to gain more power, and with the aid of a Miracle Machine and his son Kalibak – rather unwillingly – Darkseid merges with the Spectre and attacks the new team on the block.

Flipping heck!

Not that the Spirit of Vengeance goes quietly – even as Darkseid fights the newborn JLU he’s lecturing the villain about his place in the universe.

Darkseid puts the knowledge, along with power he’s stolen from various magical beings, to good/bad use and grows to greater godhood.

There’s a lot more going on in the script by Joshua Williamson and Scott Snyder, but this is a big story and I heartily recommend you give it a look. I will say that one of the best aspects of the issue is that it gives one of my favourites, Booster Gold, a big role. Heck, he was getting so much attention and respect I expected Max Lord to show up and shoot him in the head. But no, he’s alive as we reach the cliffhanger, which is a winner.

The big takeout of this issue is that not only do we get the birth of Justice League Unlimited, we get new, but familiar, heroes on the parallel Earth christened The Elseworld.

Well, they look a fun time.

We get to meet Absolute Wonder Woman, Superman and Batman in the next few weeks in their own books. For now, let’s concentrate on this comic.

It was a lot better than expected. Well, I expected to enjoy the Justice League half, and I did – it’s full of hope and heroism, heroes who smile. The Darkseid section I expected to bore me rigid. I mean, how many times do we have to see Old Stone Face plotting to take over Earth One or Prime or whatever it’s called this month? But I enjoyed it hugely, thanks in part to the intense, well-constructed script, which captures classic Darkseid while making him seem a little more evil, a little smarter. And then there’s the art of illustrator Wes Craig and colourist Mike Spicer, which barrels through the back half of the comic like a bullet train. It’s direct, dynamic and occasionally has a vibe of the late, great Darwyn Cooke. I love it.

As for the pages drawn by Daniel Sampere and coloured by Alejandro Sánchez, they’re more in the DC house style, but elevated. The clean lines are just what the first half of the book, steeped in the optimism of a fresh start for superheroes, needs. And when all hell breaks loose and Darkseid attacks after breaking through from his half of the issue – Apokolips is in a separate dimension to Earth and travel between the two is usually a matter of Boom Tubes – Sampere brings the power he applied to his now classic Action Comics run.

There’s a third artist on the book and that’s Dan Mora, who handles a chaotic cosmic spread connecting the two halves of the whole. Coloired by Tamra Bonvillain, it’s a terrific take on some Absolute characters DC hadn’t previewed and I love it

One query about the art… for a few panels around the Darkseid fight, Batman seems to have gone full metal knight.

I like the look, but is it a costume mode I’ve not come across?

The business about Superman energy setting the tone for the universe is objectively weird, but it’s not new, having been established in Doomsday Clock #12. I’d assumed that piece of Geoff Johns-ery would never be referenced again, so it’s fascinating to see it used.

So, on the same day this week DC released the end of one crossover in Absolute Power #4 and the beginning of a new publishing initiative in this very comic. It’s exhausting but a heck of a lot of fun.

Just buy this comic in print if you possibly can.

6 thoughts on “DC All In Special #1 review

  1. I had to rush reading the issue so I could read your review. There is some promise to this conceit: good being the underdog, but that will depend on the execution. It’ll also depend on the integral honesty of the writing, i.e., if Darkseid is the centre of evil, and Superman is the centre of good, will that be explored or lessened so we can see a lower tier character shine? Will Green Arrow save the day with a lucky shot or will we get Beowulf vs Grendel on a multi-universal scale? I’ll be reading and as always, great review.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. i had to read this online too, as my LCS sold out of it in the 4 hours it had been on sale before I got there. (A good sign, I hope!) I share your frustration with Amazon’s Kindle reader. It’s lousy for 2-page spreads.

    I’m so glad you liked Wes Craig’s art! I rushed through that half the first time, but when I reread it I really loved it! So much energy on the page, and such great layouts!

    And the center spread surprise! I couldn’t be more excited. I think this is an excellent step regarding something that’s been on my wishlist for AGES.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. The JLU stuff was a fun read. It looked great and dialog was exceptional. I forget, did Booster get home? I hope so because the one of the only Johns tweaks to a character I like is the one for Booster. Heck, even Jurgens seems to like it as he’s used it and eh created Booster. The set up and large cast would be something I usually don’t trust to be a great story generator but if you can’t trust Waid who can you trust?

    The Absolute half I just skipped since I don’t plan on reading one page of that initiative. A Batman who looks like Inferior 5’s The Blimp and Wonder Woman with a sword, let alone one bigger than her, are two visuals that turn me off without having to read a word. Angsty looking Superman didn’t have me deciding to skip it but it being partnered with two books I already thumbsed down on did. Plus there’s the fact Snyder loves pure darkness with very little balance of late and that’s not my jam. It just doesn’t feel like heroic fiction.

    Oh and a pic I saw that tries to justify that stupid Bat-symbol on Bruce’s chest as an ax head he can detach and use. More reason not to even sample the Absolute books.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Absolute stuff doesn’t appeal to me at all, which is why I was so surprised to enjoy the All-In story. I’ll likely have a skim once it’s at DC Infinite. I’d not be surprised were DC to put the first issues up day and date, as they do with the odd special.

      Like

Leave a reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.