Superman #3 review

‘Superman vs the unstoppable Rogol Zaar!’ is what the cover promises. We don’t get that this issue, but it is coming. What we do get is the best Superman story since Brian Michael Bendis took over the character.

The issue opens at STAR Labs, where supervillain Live Wire, in a quest to expand her powers, expects to be the big story. Not quite.

So much for forcing the scientists to help her upgrade her electrical abilities. Superman arrives and he has his own hopes for her.

In his other identity as a reporter, Superman is used to delivering bad news. And even though it’s the STAR guys who have put Earth in a particularly precarious position, he’s not angry at them, just sad.

Off Earth, but still in the Phantom Zone, Rogol Zaar – the alien who claims to have killed Krypton – meets one of the inter-dimensional prison’s longest-serving, and all-round worst, residents.

Jax-Ur intends to show Rogol Zaar who’s boss courtesy of his prison gang.

That worked well Jax-Ur, you criminal mastermind, you.

On Earth, as he staves off as many Phantom Zone-connected disasters as he can, Superman checks in with his Justice League teammates.

Then, a curt reminder to citizens of Metropolis not to give in to their worst urges.

img_4798And a visit to the Hall of Justice, where a cerebellum of super-scientists, with the refreshing exception of Blue Beetle Ted Kord, is having a bit of a panic.

FFC2CD27-9586-408B-9B1F-2927A3135FDCBy issue’s end, Zaar and his new army of Phantom Zoners are ready for a raid on Earth. Superman knows it, but he ain’t cowering.

There’s so much good stuff here. Superman believing Livewire has a better side. Him having a sharp word with regular people who are helping themselves rather than helping out in a crisis. Ray Palmer pulling rank on Mr Oh-So-Terrific followed by his understandable incredulity that STAR scientists are yet again diving into mad science with little thought for the consequences. Jimmy Olsen being used in an understated, but logical, manner.

And finally – finally! – we get a sense that Rogol Zaar has potential as an ongoing foe, his calm takedown of Jax-Ur, both verbal and physical, giving him some much-needed villainous charisma. So far he’s simply been Doomsday with a bigger vocabulary.

Oh, and there’s an utterly wonderful one-page gag showcasing one of my favourite DC B-listers, which I shan’t spoil.

There’s art to astonish courtesy of penciller Ivan Reis, inkers Joe Prado and Oclair Albert, colourist Alex Sinclair and letterer Josh Reed. Reis uses smallness to sell that above-mentioned joke, while he goes big, very big, in order to show what a threat Zaar is to, well, just about everybody. The compassion on Superman’s face at various points is glorious, while Reis’s formidable, ready-for-anything Man of Steel is stellar.

And I’m most intrigued by the background details of Batman With Vomiting Action – bell, book and candle? Was he trying a spell to help Earth?


The regular cover by Reis, Prado and Sinclair is decent, but the variants are outstanding, with Adam Hughes’ Clark image just pipping David Mack’s lovely nod to Superman #1 as my favourite (I wonder why he didn’t come up with this two months ago…).

I can’t fault Bendis for his understanding of Superman – this is a hero who inspires, who cares, a man who is here to help rather than judge, someone who leads not because he thinks he’s the best, but because others look to him. And in Reis and friends, Bendis has partners who can translate his vision into truly memorable visuals.

Suddenly, I’m excited.

3 thoughts on “Superman #3 review

  1. Man, I’m so glad this run has finally grabbed you. I tend to like Action Comics more than Superman right now, but Bendis & Reis really are starting to build Rogol Zaar into more than he started as (or more than was initially apparent, at least), and the moments with Livewire, the looters, and the “meanwhile, back where Earth ought to be” interlude were really special and fun.

    I’m not sure why the poison is hitting Batman worse than, say, Ryan Choi, but I’m fine with it. (Maybe it’s a function of how much he exerts himself, breathing harder than heaver than a guy standing in a lab.)

    Looking forward to more!


    1. The difference in poisoning time is pretty typical Bendis, something inconsistent serving the story. Still, I’m in a forgiving mood.

      Maybe we could say all his exposure to Scarecrow’s fear gas and Joker poison and Bane venom has made him weaker where poisons are concerned. We could also argue for the opposite angle.


  2. Good points. And then again, it’s a toxin, and different people react differently to different toxins, regardless of fitness. My wife is in ten times better shape than I am, but we were doing basically the same yardwork a couple of weeks ago — and she’s STILL suffering from the worst case of poison ivy she’s ever had. Me? Not a bit of it.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.