
Composition, execution, colours, title design – that’s a stunning cover from Mikel Janín. It’s kicking off the six-part finale to Janín and writer Tom Taylor’s run on Detective Comics, and begs the question: how are they going to get a 120pp story out of the idea that anyone believes Clark Kent could be a killer?
That’s the mystery that’ll get me buying, I guess. And of course, there’s the question of who is framing Clark. He’s in the police’s sights after Smallville High classmate Esme, daughter of the Mayor, is shot to death at the local sports stadium. We see her call out Clark’s name as the off-panel assailant takes aim. Superman hears the news three days later after helping a class of kids whose school bus has a burst tyre.

While Lois is all for launching an investigation to prove her husband’s innocence. Superman decides Clark must turn himself in and flies to the Smallville Sheriff’s Office: ‘This is a job for Clark.’

One job Clark hasn’t done is answer the phone to Batman. That doesn’t stop their fellow Justice League members from assuming the Caped Crusader is on top of things.

Dismissing the big Leaguers with a curt ‘Do not get in the way of my investigation’, Batman jets off to Smallville and uses Bat-CSI Goggles to tell him about the crime scene and corpse. He also breaks into Esme’s phone and learns that her last call was to Clark Kent.
Finally, he drops in on Clark.

And wouldn’t you know it, Clark doesn’t actually know if he killed Esme.
What’s that all about? Has Clark been having blackouts? Holy Gangbuster, Batman! I guess we’ll find out next time, but I’m betting on the Parasite impersonating him, or a Durlan, or a rogue Clark robot…
Meanwhile, am I the only person sick to the back teeth of the League showing up in members’ books to lecture them about something or other? We’ve only just had it in Flash, and I swear it’s happened somewhere else recently, more than once. To be fair, given the way Wally West has been acting of late, it’s justified, but here? The Leaguers have pretty much all been in the same position at some point and things got sorted. And thank you Black Lightning, of course Superman will be at your side if needed. Meanwhile, leave it to the World’s Finest team to clear Clark’s name.
Or better still, Batman alone – this is his book, and Clark’s not likely to leave his cell to defend his reputation, it’d be breaking the law. Heck, those Bat-CSI Goggles Taylor introduces could likely crack the case by themselves.
I enjoyed this. Moments such as Superman not leaving the kids after helping them, but showing them how to change a tyre, and automatically floating as he kisses Lois, great stuff.
Batman appearing in Superman’s locked cell, though… does he have a very quiet Boom Tube in the CSI Bat-Goggles? It’s undeniable Janín draws the heck out of the scene, but I really do want to know how Batman got in there – presumably the cells don’t have service tunnels above them.
And I hate Clark floating over Batman in his cell; even if Batman has disabled all cameras, who’s to say the sheriff won’t suddenly appear? And physical and visual dominance over his pals shouldn’t be a Superman thing.
As the first chapter of a serial, this is a cracking read, with its confident script and gorgeous full-colour art – whether we’re in bright daylight or near total darkness, Jańin nails it, while his storytelling and figurework is as fine as it’s been since he popped up on DC readers’ radar with Grayson. The only thing I don’t like is his approach to Batman’s ears, they’re too wide and flat. Still, the overall excellence leaves room for Taylor to provide another level of storytelling with his narration and dialogue, nicely laid out by Wes Abbott.
The comic left me wanting to know what happens next; it’s done its job with style.