The Joker #1 review

Riddle me this? When is a Joker comic not a Joker comic?

When the star of the show is Jim Gordon. Sure, the Clown Prince of crime appears throughout the issue, but it’s in flashback, or he’s an eerie figure haunting Gotham’s recently retired police commissioner. Joker #1 is a terrific study of Gordon, laying out his relationship to the villain and giving us someone to be a hero figure, because while the Joker of the short-lived Seventies series was basically a fun fella, today’s sadistic psychopath isn’t anyone to root for.

The issue opens with Jim remembering an encounter with a fellow cop on his last night in Chicago, before his anti-corruption crusade saw him kicked over to Gotham.

Ryan tells Gordon of the night he faced a cannibal killer, an encounter he’s never been able to forget. He wonders, does Gordon have his own bogeyman?

The answer would be, not yet – but within a few years that’s all changed, as the Joker begins to stalk Gotham, tormenting and murdering not just strangers but Gordon’s loved ones.

Gordon is reviewing his history as he’s called to the scene of a tragedy – a series of bombs planted at Arkham Asylum have killed hundreds of staff and patients. Some of the city’s most dangerous psychopaths have escaped and the new mayor has a proposition for Gordon.

Soon, though, he’s approached again… but not by the authorities.

Gordon still isn’t inclined to allow the Joker to dominate his waking hours in the same way that the ghoul haunts his sleep, but the people Cressida represents offer something the Mayor doesn’t – a much-needed, rather massive, retirement fund. There’s one catch.

Gordon is given until the end of the week to consider the offer.

Meanwhile, in Belize…

And so the first chapter ends, with Gordon looking set to take up a new role as Joker hunter and hitman. But who would he be working for? Gotham’s most powerful criminals? Or the Joker himself, ready to play a new game with the man whose life he destroyed?

I’ll certainly be back next time to see if we get any answers. I wasn’t going to try this series, being plum Jokered out, but Friend of the Blog Rob Staeger recommend it based on a preview, and I’m so glad he did. This is writer James Tynion IV at his best, crafting a compelling character study using established history while moving forward into new territory. James Gordon is Batman’s oldest supporting character and Tynion shows that despite what the man himself may think, there’s a lot of life in the old dog yet. The narrative tone is spot on, revelatory without being too self-conscious, and the dialogue works throughout.

Guillem March’s gritty illustrative style is just right for this story, his imperfect people easy to empathise with. The only ‘perfect’ person in the book is Cressida, which fits with her status as temptress. And even she has a wounded knee. The detailed backgrounds anchor the story’s wilder elements, there’s a nice nod to classic artist Jim Aparo in March’s Gordon, and his Joker is suitably horrific. Also, keep an eye out for the Edward Hopper cafe. Arif Prianto’s colours help evoke the sickness at the heart of Gotham, while Tom Napolitano’s fonts add to the creepy feel of the pages.

March and colourist Tomeu Morley’s cover is suitably inviting, although the looming Bane is lost behind the logo; still, it’s a decent clue that as Gordon suspects, Bane hasn’t died in the Arkham bombing.

This issue has a short back-up centred on the trial of Joker acolyte Punchline. It’s less compelling that the lead feature, with characters clumsily introduced and Punchline herself deeply annoying – there’s no obvious reason she looks set to rule Blackgate Prison, where guards seem not to lock the cells. But there she is, punching out a member of the Royal Flush Gang as other prisoners look on in awe.

As for why so many people in Gotham seem to be on the side of a known murderer, no idea.

Written by Sam Johns with Tynion, decently illustrated by Mirka Andolfo in scratchy style and with colours by Romulo Fajardo Jr and letters by Ariana Maher, Punchline doesn’t punch up this debut issue.

Take out the back-up and Joker #1 would be a five-star spectacular. As it is, it’s still worth your time and money as a brilliant look at Jim Gordon.

7 thoughts on “The Joker #1 review

  1. Oh, man, I’m so glad you liked it!

    And you liked it so much I might actually buy it too. That’s downright weird, considering how tired I am of the Joker. But I *do* love Jim Gordon, and I *do* love detective manhunts. I swear, if this book was called anything else, and if the killer was named Jeff or something, I wouldn’t hesitate.


  2. I am shocked by how much I liked Joker #1. I, too, could use a clown-cation away from the Joker, but Tynion’s run on Batman has been so good that I have it a try. I’m glad I did. I am all in on a Jim Gordon book. In fact, the Joker’s appearance at the end of the issue was the least interesting element. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Sean, I wonder if this book will be a bit of a global ride – I’d love to see Knight and Squire take on the Joker again, they could give him a big punch on behalf of the dear, departed Jarvis Poker.


  3. I am shocked by how much I liked Joker #1. I, too, could use a clown-cation away from the Joker, but Tynion’s run on Batman has been so good that I have it a try. I’m glad I did. I am all in on a Jim Gordon book. In fact, the Joker’s appearance at the end of the issue was the least interesting element. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Thanks for the review, Mart — I loved the lead story. I haven’t actually read this kind of story in a while, so I think it’ll be a refreshing change of pace for me, even considering the Joker’s involvement.

    And I agree with Sean that the Joker’s appearance at the end was the least compelling part of the book. Oh, look! He’s murdered people capriciously! Yawn. BUT — if next issue, Jim travels around Belize and puts a few missing person cases together, and figures out where the Joker is staying because they’re all associated with the same villa? That’s fantastic — the sort of detective work you rarely see Batman get to do. Usually it’s just exposition delivered to him by Oracle: “I did some digging, Bruce, and it turns out they all work at…” — shorthand exposition that lets us fast-forward to the action. But by having Jim do the legwork, we get a suspense and mystery book instead of an action book. THAT, I’m down for.

    As for Punchline, I’m lukewarm on the feature so far. I barely remembered Bluebird and her brother from Snyder’s time on the Bat, but I’m glad they’re being used. And I’m honestly more interested if Punchline turns out to be a stealth Bluebird series in the same way Joker is a stealth Jim Gordon book. But this is my first encounter with Punchline, and she hasn’t impressed me yet.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m all on for a proper detection book, it really is rare in comics and on TV (have you seen British cold case series Unforgotten? No chases, just a team of cops going around asking questions and digging through things… mind, that makes it sound a lot duller than it is!).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.