Dark Crisis: World Without a Justice League – Superman #1 review

Dark Crisis: World Without a Justice League – Superman. That’s a bit of a mouthful as titles go, but it does make clear what’s going on with the two stories in this Dark Crisis spin-off. Two? Yep, because as well as a main strip starting Superman and Superboy, there’s a back-up centring on Aquaman and his family.

To be fair, Aquaman does get billing on the cover, but it’s very subtle, and not using one of his known logos. It’s probably fair to say most people will be here for Superman and Super Son, intrigued as to why Jon is dressed in a Robin-style costume. And the ansŵer is…

… er, sorry. Writer Tom King doesn’t explain that one. A tease to bring in a few Batman fans, perhaps? Anyway, we do get a look at a world in which Clark, Superman and Lois Kent live in domestic bliss.

But Jon starts having disturbed nights, his super senses bringing hints that all isn’t well ‘Out there’ (that’s the name of the story).

Little by little, in chapters giving snapshots of Jon’s life from the ages of 13 to 18, we see how Jon deals with the knowledge that what’s out there is Darkseid, and learn that Superman had made a peace pact with the lord of Apokolips. Darkseid has always liked a good peace pact.

But the bad guy isn’t the point of this story, the point is that we’re on a world where Superman of the regular DC Universe gets to live another life. A life in which he doesn’t miss his son’s teenage years. And this motivates a final page that’s very touching – Tom King is terrific at writing parental love.

If you liked ‘For the Man Who Has Everything’ or stories in which the Justice League battles Dr Destiny, you’ll likely enjoy this. It follows the template of ‘perfect world with reality scratching at the edges’ to a tee. Apart from Jon being a sweary little fella – everyone curses in King comics – the Kents are recognisable, with Lois especially fun. It’s sad to see Clark so afraid to go beyond Earth, but my guess is that he and Jon are the only superheroes the planet has – King could usefully have spelled this out.

One curiosity: Lois mentions to Jon that her stomach is bothering her… how is there not a new superbaby within a few months? And one note: Tom King really wants us to think he hates Adam Strange.

Chris Burnham makes one of his too-rare DC appearances, his wonderfully organic art giving the story a pleasantly human feel. He’s great at emotion, capturing the concern Lois and Clark have for their growing boy. As for the action beats, highlights include a big fight against Brainiac and a bone-crunching encounter with Orion of the New Gods.

And I do like details such as Jon casually crushing the door frame before breakfast.

The sympathetic colours of Adriano Lucas add another dimension of comic book goodness, while the hand-drawn feel of Troy Peteri’s letters adds to the rough and ready tone. Burnham and Lucas’s cover totally has that Batman and Robin sensibility, I love it. It’s a shame the classic Superman logo isn’t there, it’s not appearing on any DC comics at the moment, which is wrong – it’s part of the visual iconography of not just DC Comics, but the entire industry.

Aquaman, meanwhile, is in a world of his own. All the current Justice League heroes are, courtesy of the newly evil Pariah in the aforementioned Dark Crisis. Things are terribly bright in Aquaman’s corner of the Multiverse, with Mera ruling at his side, daughter Andi all grown up, both his father and mother alive and happy… even Black Manta is a pal!

And that’s it, really, even a minor supervillain can’t wreck the fun of Aquaparents’ wedding renewal ceremony, thanks to Andi’s amour Jess Quick. But…

It looks like Arthur isn’t as locked into Black Pariah’s fantasy world as the hero turned villain – well, nutter – would have hoped. I look forward to seeing what comes next. For now, this is a fun little tale.. it’s just a shame Arthur Jr doesn’t make an appearance. Wrong continuity, probably. Anyway, writer Brandon Thomas, artist Fico Ossio, colourist Sebastian Cheng and letterer Troy Peteri (using a more conventional font) do a cracking job, there’s a confidence and elegance to proceedings. Ossio delivers one panel that’s a veritable crowd of Atlantean supporting characters, even Silver Age sea sprite Quisp pops up, and it made me smile.

All in all, Dark Crisis: World Without a Justice League – Superman is a good-looking tie-in to an intriguing event.

6 thoughts on “Dark Crisis: World Without a Justice League – Superman #1 review

  1. Good story. Better than what I could have anticipated. Only criticism I have is the parenting moment when Jon wakes from hearing innocents being murdered by Orion. The use of language and the total disrespectful tone towards Superman is just too much to tolerate. Children don’t get to be rude or disrespectful because they’re children. Parents don’t walk away from kids when they’re in the wrong only to return saying they will “do better”. Somewhere along the line, disciplining children became a no-no, even when the child is wrong. Jon is out of line, full stop. Jon gets to be critical because Superman is there keeping the planet safe, including him. It’s the low point of an otherwise top story.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I realise that writers can writer characters that don’t speak for them but King is so into the casual effing and jeffing that I do wonder how the conversations go in his house. Jon Kent isn’t a kid to be casually cursing.


  2. I’m not sure how much Superman does or does not remember his life on Earth-Zero. But I think he’s trying to keep Jon close to home to avoid what happened when he let him go off with Jor-El. Having seen him through adolescence this time, he does let him go off at last.

    Is that Adam Strange lying among the skulls? Yeah, probably.

    I don’t agree about the lettering. Peteri’s lettering is acceptable in the second story – a bit quirky, but acceptable. But in the first story, he’s doing something similar to the left-leaning semi-italic stylized thing that Pat Brousseau commonly does that annoys me so much. I don’t know why, but it gives me a headache.

    I think Fico Ossio is an outstanding artist, but I think he sabotages his own work with his crazy, cluttered, and (to me) distracting page compositions. His artwork is so good, but is not enhanced by any of this stuff. It’s so offputting to me that I hesitated to read the backup. But ultimately, I did, and it was decent if slight.

    I own the Ossio-drawn “Mister Miracle: The Source of Freedom” mini-series from a couple of years back. Same problem – great art sometimes lost in visual overwhelm. Since he had a whole series to work with, he didn’t lay into the chaos on every page, but it does increase as the story builds to its close.

    Oh, one more thing: I saw an interview with King and Burnham. Burnham said the script called for him to draw Jon like Robin, and he decided to take that quite literally. (The colors are quite not the same – Jon has blue and black rather than green, etc. But the domino mask and tunic sure are Robin-like.) I wonder what the idea was — maybe that Superman had never seen Jon at these ages, but he knew Dick Grayson, so that’s what he’s imagining?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. As ever, thanks for the comments and information. That’s definitely Adam Strange, poor guy. That’s him dead in two DC weeks in a row…

      Peteri’s lettering wasn’t my favourite, but I can’t see if spreading across the line.

      I don’t recall seeing Ossio’s art previously, I avoided that Shilo Norman mini, I’ve just never found him interesting. He needs his own ID.


  3. The comic is titled Dark Crisis Wolrd Without a Justice League, so he did kinda tell you Supes and Supes Jr were the only ones. 🙂

    I like the cover a lot, and tjhis would seem to be an Earth where Superman and son sort of take on characteristics of all the known super-heroes, such as the Earth 2 S on Supes’ chest, and the Robin style costume, etc. I wish DC had special imprints of books based on other universes. Earth S, Earth 2, Earth C, etc. Maybe even just as quarterlies. I am really not that fond of their current status quo on Earth Prime.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.