Heroes in Crisis #3 review

Heroes in therapy. That’s what we get as the third issue of Tom King and Clay Mann’s limited series opens. Lagoon Boy, The Flash, Booster Gold, reeling off name, tagline and how long they’ve been at Sanctuary, the treatment centre for emotionally battered super-people.

Turn the page and there’s a shocking image.

Is this the end of the teenage hero?

Elsewhere in an issue that flits between characters and days, Booster Gold is welcomed by robot versions of Ma and Pa Kent and Lana Lang, before being taken to his room. (A double negative from that Pa robot? Jonathan Kent was a country guy, but he knew his grammar!)

Wally West is using Sanctuary’s Kryptonian tech to spend time with his wife and children, lost to him during a reality shift.

The issue ends with a shocking moment of violence that sheds light on the question of just who killed all those heroes in the first issue, including Lagoon Boy, Wally and Speedy.

I always liked Lagoon Boy, introduced by Erik Larsen during his underrated Aquaman run and later added to the Teen Titans. He was a fun character, but he’s spent most of his existence in comics limbo. Does that make it OK for King to eviscerate him to build stakes in his story? King goes the classic route of giving a character about to be killed the best characterisation they’ve had in years, to make their death more affecting.

Wally doesn’t need this treatment, he’s beloved by many more people than Lagoon Boy, whose entire fan club could meet on my settee. It’s depressing to see him, not exactly wallowing (Wallying?), but retreating to a world of memories and might-have-beens rather than trying to repair reality like the man of action he is.

As for Booster Gold, he doesn’t verbalise it, but seems to instinctively realise this whole Sanctuary set-up, with unseen AI therapist and anonymity guaranteed by creepy, cultish robes and masks, is a crock of crap.

Once again, the craft of Heroes in Crisis is undeniable: King’s story is very readable, with moments that are undeniably compelling. Lee Weeks draws all but the bookend pages and his work is as gorgeous as ever, with clever, subtle touches such as fingerprints in the composition of a Booster Gold page. Clay Mann’s opening and closing therapy nine-panel grids do the trick. As for the colours of Tomeu Morey and letters of Clayton Cowles, they’re outstanding.

But the whole thing once more left me feeling flat. I really liked Vision and Omega Men, but after Mr Miracle and Batman, I’m beginning to think King’s simply no longer my thing. More and more his thing is PTSD, a subject undeniably worth a tale or two, but the pervading mood of misery leaves me feeling flat. The joy of seeing a whole bunch of little-used DC types on the final page is immediately lost with the realisation that under the colourful costumes are red shirts – they’re here to die. And of course I know I’m reading a comic set in a superhero multiverse in which people regularly return to life, or pop up again as slightly tweaked versions of themselves… but seeing the likes of Nemesis and Solstice and the beyond obscure Protector all at Sanctuary has me wishing they’d form a super-team, not a mass burial. Such wasted potential.

The fundamental ‘buys’ behind the series, that a) Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman are so full of themselves that they’d set up a care home for lesser heroes and b) they’d staff it with robots and outfit it like a cult are things I can’t accept. The DCU is full of wise women and men who could be trusted to listen to lost souls who wanted to refer themselves to them. Maybe the arrogance and stupidity of the ‘Trinity’ is going to be a story point, but for now, it’s a stumbling block.

So what did you think?

12 thoughts on “Heroes in Crisis #3 review

  1. Thanks for the review – I cancelled this series after issue #2. The poor characterisation of Booster Gold, Harley defeating Superman, Wonder Woman and Batman so easily, not to mention the casual discarding of Wally…

    Not my cup of tea at all, and your review makes me think I’m not missing anything.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Yeah, I’m guessing King just isn’t your thing anymore. I’m sorry to hear it — this story is working like Gangbusters for me. All that craft (which you acknowledge) and yet with me, it’s striking the right chord.

    Boy, do I not like to see Nemesis on that last page. Or Solstice, though I just remember her pre-New52 incarnation. But Nemesis…

    Will you look at that. The Kryptonian tech isn’t the only master of disguise in the house.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. “It’s depressing to see him, not exactly wallowing…” Wally has been told he needs to come to terms with his loss. I don’t think he’s EVER had to do that before. Does he even know how? I don’t think he even remembers Barry’s death. It’s no surprise if his process is less than perfect. Not sure any process is.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Irony: A speedster is killed while standing still…
    The masks still remind me of the Medusa Mask… Would the Psycho Pirate be too obvioust?
    Or maybe the AI decided that death is the ultimate cure?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The latter idea sounds very likely. Definitely, many of us said ‘Medusa mask’ when the art for this series began to emerge – it’s one of my favourite DC props, so creepy and great looking.

      Like

  5. Thanks for review. I’m contmplating my future with the story.

    I loved Mr Miracle. The PTSD, the ‘is It real’, the violence vs family love – that all worked. But this isn’t working. It reads flat. I’m not invested in these characters or their stories here. And it just pales nexts to MM which captivated.

    Sigh.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.