Superman #1 review

Superman has flown into space, looking for his family. Lois and Jon left with Clark’s dodgy dad Jor-El for a summer adventure, but he’s lost contact and is desperate to find them. So desperate that after a run-in with evil aliens The Dominators…

… he gives up and flies home.

Back on Earth, he sets up a new Fortress of Solitude to replace the one blown up in his recent fight with Rogol Zaar, the man who killed Kandor and claims to have destroyed Krypton.

At the Daily Planet, Clark receives a summons from J’onn J’onnz, the Martian Manhunter. He wants a little chat. Every few sentences, Clark is called away to deal with some emergency or other. Finally, though, Clark gets to hear Jonn’s suggestions.

Well, that obviously isn’t the real J’onn J’onnz, and it seems Superman has his suspicions too, although so far as we know, he doesn’t scan the figure before him to check it’s his fellow Justice Leaguer. If it does turn out to be the real thing, then Brian Michael Bendis, whose presence as new writer of the Man of Tomorrow supposedly justifies a fresh volume of Superman, gets the Martian Manhunter about as well as he does the Flash (‘I meant caca poo poo on some level’). Because the real Martian Manhunter knows that if he’s in his right mind, Superman would never deign to attempt to lead the people of Earth into some airy fairy new era, never mind take over the world. Clark sees himself as being alongside the people of Earth, not above them – time and again he’s concluded that they must make their own destiny.

J’onn would never condemn the planet as ‘garbage’. He’s not as beloved as Superman, sure; that’s partly because he chooses a form that doesn’t reflect any Earth race, and partly because he doesn’t mingle the way Clark does. Yet he’s always been shown as a fan of Earth, ready to believe the best of the people he protects. The guy shown here is truly alien, more White Martian than Green.

My other big problem is that Bendis has Superman abandon his search for Lois and Jon on a whim. One minute he’s ‘ I HAVE TO FIND MY FAMILY’ and the next it’s a case of Earth, which has a zillion superheroes, needing him more than his wife and child, who are in the hands of a version of his father who is, to say the least, deeply unstable.

Plus, Bendis has Clark come out with stupid statements.


No, you do not. Lois is a truly formidable person, but she’s not super-powered; on Earth she’s needed rescuing by him hundreds of times, and in space the dangers are magnified many times. She needs him, and Jon needs him and, just as importantly, he needs them. Look at how Clark mopes in a couple of nicely done flashback scenes.

Stupid statement numbers two and three.

Is Superman really so Earth-centric that he can’t fathom that the Dominators could be up to anything, going anywhere? Earth is, literally, a long way from being threatened, but there he is, possibly killing people. And what does he mean, they’ll wonder how their invasion was stopped? He’s right there in their faces – unless he’s actually killing every last Dominator before they can send a signal home.

I like that Bendis prefers a gentle Superman, as seen in the exchanges with J’onn, but he should never be so ‘nice’ that he’d not properly challenge a friend who suggests he, er, takes over the world.

Earlier in the issue, Clark is looking for a chance to change into his uniform.

What are we to make of this? Does the unnamed kid know Clark is Superman, hence he’s looking upwards as our hero, presumably, leaves the building?

The new Fortress of Solitude skews towards the cinema version, all boring icy spikes. Still, the classic will be back at some point. Talking of the Fortress, I could have done without this joke.

Too self-indulgent by half from the Portland-based writer.

I liked the art team of penciller Ivan Reis and inker Joe Prado, but then I always do; they produce good-looking work, clear with strong storytelling. Superman has rarely emoted so subtly. I think this is my favourite panel.

Well, that building, popularly known as the Gherkin, is in London – how could I not like it?

The colours of Alex Sinclair and letters of Josh Reed are as good as every, helping carry the story along, and the cover by Reis, Prado and Sinclair is pleasantly cheery, if not a standout.

The first issue of a new Superman comic should feel special. This feels distinctly OK, with demerits for the waving away of the search for Lois and John, and the appalling mischaracterisation of J’onn J’onnz. I was planning on giving this series a few issues, but if the next chapter doesn’t show a big improvement, I’m probably out. No Lois, no Jon, a Superman who’s dangerously close to passive…. for this, DC cancelled the joyful, quirky Tomasi & Gleason run, and the confident, pacy Jurgens series? That’s actually a little depressing.

14 thoughts on “Superman #1 review

  1. I was horribly disappointed by this issue. And Rogol Zaar is back next issue as the unfinished story from Man of Steel plods along. frustratingly so.

    Is the building so nicknamed because it’s shaped like a pickle?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It is indeed. The real name is 30 St Mary Axe – snappy!

      And yes, this was really not great. And I was so jazzed by the first page, of course he’d move heaven and early to find his family. But only an inch or two, it seems.


  2. I assume the unnamed Planet kid is just rolling his eyes at Clark being the office weirdo, but that’s a guess. An “Um, alright then?” kind of expression instead of an eye roll might have been better.

    Beautifully drawn, inked and coloured like everything else in the book though! Reis, Prado and their colourist are all fantastic at giving us a Superman world that’s just realistic and fantastic enough without one ever taking away from the other. Hope they stick around after Bendis moves on.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Like you I was hoping for something tremendous to rekindle the enthusiasm. I actually enjoyed much of the issue. But the J’onn speech, which makes absolutely no sense coming from him, was like a anchor dragging me down.

    The art is beautiful. The progression of art from big splashes to smaller panels all worked. Even the Planet scene (I think the kid is rolling his eyes like ‘whatevs’ to Clark going into a closet) worked with Clark not printing a self-indulgent story about the new fortress.

    But J’onn asking Superman to become a despot? Yeesh.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. If Superman does take over the Earth, I hope he at least wears that groovy crown from Action Comics #311.

      Oh, and calling this issue the start of ‘The Unity Saga’ rings alarm bells… sounds like it could go on for ages. Calling Chris Roberson…


  4. Arrgh… I’m apparently still adjusting to the quirks of commenting on WordPress, and a long comment about this issue has been apparently never been posted. So suffice it to say, for now, that I liked this issue a bit better than you did…but you might have to consult hypertime for the reasons why.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. One thing I remember writing about — and it’s not addressed in the issue — is that no matter how worried he is, Superman is still probably better served by sitting tight on Earth, at least until he has some clue about which direction he should go. Lois is probably looking for a way to communicate, too, but that will do no good if Superman’s not on Earth to receive it. It’s harder for two parties to contact each other if neither knows where the other is than if one knows where the other is.

        And another thing was me reading a line about the Dominators a little more generously than you did. “Dominators will wonder for years how their invasion was thwarted…” I took to include how their invasion was *detected.* It’s clear to those Dominators (who I trust survived) that Superman stopped them. But they’ll wonder why he was in the area. The caption has some imprecise language, but thwarted is more dramatic than detected, so for me it’s a wash. YMMV.

        Like you, though, I’m frustrated by the sidelining of the arsonist plotline. And suspicious of J’onn — although I do have some sympathy when he calls our wars, borders, and money “garbage.” But that just be my Orange Malaise talking.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. Also, you’re not the only one who’s suggested that this may not be the real J’onn…and the other person I’ve seen said that Miss Martian is acting similarly sketchy. (I don’t read Titans, so I’m not sure what’s raising red flags.) Something may be going on that we’re just getting hints of now.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good point about Superman sitting tight. And he and Lois work in communication, so they should be able to think of something.

      Speaking of communication, I prefer precise language to dramatic; they certainly aren’t mutually exclusive, and if a writer’s meaning is lost because he prefers a little more bombast, he should have another go.


  6. I have to tell you when I read this issue I thought surely this wasn’t the same writer that did the Man of Steel mini. His characterization of Superman here is way off from what I saw there. This Superman seems, I dunno, a bit daft. I also wonder how it is that he spots Dominators out in the galaxy somewhere and he immediately knows they are headed right for Earth.

    Are we sure Bendis wrote Man of Steel? Are we sure he wrote this if he did write that?

    I was left confused. Could Superman be in some kind of dream state? I mean, J’onn telling him he should take over the world? WTF?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.