Squadron Supreme #1 review

There’s a new Squadron Supreme in town and they mean business. Survivors of five different Earths lost in the recent Secret Wars, they’ve banded together to make sure nothing kills their new home. And the first act of this band of multiversal refugees – Nighthawk, Princess Power, Hyperion, Blur and Dr Spectrum – is to get revenge on Prince Namor. The Sub-Mariner destroyed Dr Spectrum’s planet and she wants her pound of flesh. 

A confrontation with Namor and his armies goes beyond anything that might be expected, and the world reacts. People who have lost loved ones due to the actions of metahumans are all for a tougher approach to protecting the planet. Others believe the more regulated approach of the Avengers – well, those Avengers who weren’t members of the Illuminati – is the way forward. 
Me, I’m keen to see where things are going. Marvel have tried several times to recapture the lightning in a bottle that was the Mark Gruenwald/Bob Hall/Paul Ryan maxi-series. That saw a version of the team try to reshape their world into a Utopia, and it was magical. This launch looks to feature the Princess Power from that landmark book and the Nighthawk from the J Michael Straczynski version, I’m not sure. It probably doesn’t matter, as this launch’s writer, James Robinson, has the talent and drive to create something new from the pieces he’s selected. 
I’m interested to see where things go as the Squadron’s stated aim to take a firm grip of the planet can’t but put them on a collision course with Earth’s more traditional heroes. Unless this series is going to feature the Squadron Supreme vs a team of differently self-righteous metahumans every issue, I can’t see where it can go. 
But I look forward to finding out. Especially as Thundra is taking an interest in the Squadron, and I’ve had a soft spot for Marvel’s favourite Femizon ever since I saw her drawn by the sublime Ramona Fradon way back in a Seventies Fantastic Four. 
And I’ve enjoyed Leonard Kirk’s art since he co-created – with Barbara Randall Kesel – Marvel’s vastly underused Ultra Girl back in 1997. His pencils remain a pleasure, suiting the big-scale battles of this opener. There’s one moment in particular in which he really captures the shock of what’s happened… 
Kirk is paired with inker Paul Neary and the puzzle is, where did the latter go? Neary is a proper old school illustrator, a real craftsman who can do pencils, inks or both, but I can’t see his imprint at all; it’s as if Kirk’s pencils were given straight to colourist Frank Martin. The pages look good, but with Neary named alongside Kirk I expected something stronger. 
Alex Ross’ cover is good-looking, but it feels like I’ve seen this shiny image of constipated characters a million times previously.  
This first issue didn’t knock my socks off – it’s pretty much all action, and character is where Robinson excels – but the record of the creators involved means it merits a second look. Perhaps in time it’ll be Supreme, but so far this Squadron is merely So-So. 

10 thoughts on “Squadron Supreme #1 review

  1. There are so many parts of this that I love (Robinson, Kirk, Neary, alternate earths, Thundra, DP7 and, most importantly, Squadron Supreme itself), but this issue failed to really excite me.

    Firstly, I'm just gutted that the New Universe and the Squadron's reality are both gone (Supreme Power's I can happily do without). Secondly, while I understand their motivation, their actions smack of terrorism and that leaves me a little uncomfortable. Thirdly, Namor's death seemed a little anti-climactic.

    The uber-geek in me is screaming that the Blur should be in his fifties or sixties now, as the New Universe took place in “real time” rather than “comic time”. But I've had a very strong word with myself and have let it go.

    But I've got faith in the creative team. I know that, given the chance and sufficient book sales, this will all play out well. And I REALLY love Thundra, so I'm just glad of the excuse to see her more often. So I'll be sticking with this title for as long as Robinson is writing it.


  2. This issue wasn't bad, but… SPOILERS

    Now that Secret Wars issue 9 is out, I'm wondering whether Marvel editorial really knows what the ending was about. My take on it, based on the scene where the Black Panther returns to the initial pages of New Avengers #1, is that NONE of Hickman's Avengers run happened. And yet, we have the Squadron taking down Namor BECAUSE of something he did in Hickman's run. This really needs to be explained.
    Maybe that's not what Hickman intended, but I can't come up with any other interpretation. It's pretty clear right there on the page that the Panther returns to New Avengers #1 and the panels play out exactly the same, except that instead of discovering the incursions, Wakanda launches a spaceship.


  3. Now that's interesting. I never got beyond Secret Wars #1 – it was a heck of a slog getting through that, and Hickman's Avengers really wasn't for me. Maybe this is Marvel's version of DC's immediately post-Crisis hinterland, when continuities clashed?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.