X-Men: Legacy #1 review

This comic book boasts a fantastic collage cover – take a bow Mike Del Mundo – and a good joke relating to the protagonist’s hair.

Which is something. I began reading this with my supper, got two pages in, and swapped it for the new Wolverine and the X-Men, which was pretty good, thank you very much. I went back to Legacy post-pizza, so I wasn’t chewing two things over at once.

I do appreciate that even though this is the relaunch of a rather unloved X-book, Marvel are trying something different. After all, no one was crying out for a comic starring the mentally disabled son of Professor X, no matter how much his unlimited power set might excite us. British writer Simon Spurrier isn’t an obvious choice for a high-profile launch, while Tan Eng Huat marches to one very individual artistic drum.

So hurrah, something new and different.

And not for me. The first couple of pages throw us in at the deep end, deep inside Legion’s mind. Into a prison, the Qortex (geddit?) Complex. There, the personalities that control his various powers – once purely psionic, now more ‘think of a number’ – are tortured by The Xtractor. They dream of rebellion, and escape.

Trouble is, Spurrier dresses the scenario up with all kinds of annoyingly cutesy sci-fi terminology. Like so (click on image to enlarge).

Maybe I’ve simply not read enough science fiction, and students of the genre delight in This Kind Of Thing. Me, I glaze over as I try to connect with the story. It’s not as if I’m entirely unfamiliar with Legion, aka David Haller – I was reading New Mutants when he debuted. But back then he had a handful of personalities linked to such powers as telekinesis and pyrokinesis. Now he’s like that villain in Grant Morrison’s Doom Patrol, The Quiz, who had every power you hadn’t thought of. It seems he can do anything, but not without some random soul’s backstory being dredged up.

Legion is at a commune in India for ‘neuronauts’ – lost souls whose psychic powers have left them frail and confused – being counselled into some semblance of sanity by Merzah the Mystic, one of those streetwise Yodas beloved of comics who exists for but a short time to impart wisdom, then get killed (see also Ducra of Red Hood and the Outlaws ‘fame’). Rather unsubtly, Merzah’s surrogate dad credentials are cemented by his being unable to feel his legs just before he pops his clogs.

David is pretty self-aware, and not rattled by his prisoners’ escape attempts. He helps a distressed old neuronaut, and tries to make peace with a group of pitchfork-wielding locals. It’s when David feels Professor X’s death that all hell breaks loose, and Merzah is caught in the crossfire. Dying, he helps David see that carrying on his father’s work, showing the world that mutants aren’t all bad, is the way to go. That’s your Legacy right there, readers.

David isn’t convinced by Merzah’s entreaties that he make friends with the X-Men, having just had a rather big hiccup on his road to enlightenment, but his psychic outburst alerts them to his activities. As the issue ends, David is set to go on the run from the people most likely to accept and help him.

I enjoyed Eng Huat’s work here more than I did his Doom Patrol stint, several years ago, there’s a fascinating animation to it – at least, in the real world scenes. He takes Bill Sienkiewicz’s unique Legion design and runs with it, enjoying the madness of his hair, his lean muscularity – what we wind up with is a mutant version of Daniel Day Lewis. I wasn’t so keen on the weirdness inside David’s head, likely because I was so irritated by the words that I had a hard time marrying the images to them. The colours of Jose Villarrubia are a real asset, adding another level of separation to Legion’s two worlds.

I relished Spurrier’s non-mindscape dialogue – for once David actually sounds like a Brit. I liked Merzah, for his cheeky chappy guru-ness. The notion of a truly damaged young man trying to heal the rift between humans and mutants has potential. And Eng Huat has an artistic signature that shines on the right project.

But Lordy, those mindscape sequences, they’re virtually unreadable. Tone down the alien psychobabble, and I may try another issue. Or better still, dump such scenes completely, find some other way to make David’s situation manifest. I don’t know. What I do know is that X-Men: Legacy starring Legion is going to be a tough sell. I hope it finds an audience, but I can’t see it including me.

12 thoughts on “X-Men: Legacy #1 review

  1. I think the mindscape sequences did what they were supposed to from your reaction. It's supposed to be confusing and off putting. This ain't no cuddly mutant! This wasn't as much fun as Spurrier's Science Club mini but I loved it and am in for however long it lasts!


  2. I'm pretty sure we've already been through this with Legion, and not that long ago. Then he made peace with most of his personalities, and had a dial-h-for-hero style bracelet for using their powers. Is that out of continuity already?


  3. Steve, thanks for the reminder, I never did get round to that Science Club series.

    You may be right about Spurrier's intent with the Qortex scenes, but I disliked them so much that I'm disinclined to try the book again.


  4. I love Sci-fi, but the scenes in this felt more like a made for Syfy channel movie than good sci-fi. I was very much put off by the multiple personalities all being these stupid Syfy channel aliens and I think it would have been vastly more interesting with David doing like he USED to where he has to cajole, bargain or even plead with his personalities to get them to do what he wanted and even then it didn't always work. This to me strikes as “Hey, Legion is super powerful, let's make sure he can be super powerful for our next Marvel event where we need a reality bending mutant!”. I love the idea of multiple personalities (like with Typhoid/Bloody Mary and Aurora/Jeanne-Marie) and Legion was one of the few guys to have this problem and deal with it.. well. This is not dealing with it. It's suppressing it and hoping it'll all go away. I don't like at all.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.