
Dr Mid-Nite wakes, having been captured by the Injustice Society, and she has a guard. A very large guard.

Beth Chapel, though, has skills. Skills taught her by the likes of Batman, Mr Miracle and (of course) Wildcat. She escapes, and sneaks upon the villains as they plot.

The red-suited Johnny Sorrow has recently been impersonating JSA member Obsidian, who, we find, is also being restrained, though his guard seems most likely to kill with kindness.

Todd does get free, tapping into his shadow powers, and Obsidian finds a third captured JSA member – Jakeem Thunder.

Who’s behind the door? Probably Obsidian’s super-sweet jailer, but who is he really? Likely a super-villain – are there any light-themed Justice Society bad guys? Maybe the illusion expert Harlequin’s Son has gone properly bad?
And why can’t Jakeem call the Thunderbolt? And if this is Obsidian, who’s that Dr Mid-Nite comes across in the Injustice Society’s secret HQ?

Did the hospital scene and subsequent escape take place in Todd’s head, along with Jakeem’s Thunderbolt blip? Given last time we saw Jakeem he was in a comatose state in the JSA’s Brownstone, before Beth confronted Sorrow-as-Obsidian, it’s unlikely it’s the real teen here. So who’s been running the show? Brain Wave, maybe?
Hopefully we’ll find out the answers next time, along with more on the female Kid Eternity who greeted Hawkman at the end of last issue. This month, though, Dr Mid-Nite and Obsidian are the stars of the show, and I rather enjoyed it. I mean, Beth Chapel was created decades ago, but she was killed in the Nineties and only came back to life recently, so she’s not had much time in the spotlight. And contemporary Obsidian is often played as being off his rocker, but here he’s on great form. I wouldn’t want every issue to be like this, JSA being a team book and all, but a split showcase issue every six months would be a great way to showcase lesser-known members. And both heroes, in a sense, live their best lives in the dark.
It’s issue four and we still don’t know the criminals’ full plan, but we get a little more this issue. I’m certainly intrigued, and meanwhile getting lots of entertaining nuggets of character and action. There’s no denying, though, that people who read this story in a collected edition will get the best experience.
Writer Jeff Lemire does a good job distinguishing the voices of Obsidian and Dr Mid-Nite, but he’s still failing to properly introduce characters. Scandal Savage, for instance, has a prominent role here and isn’t identified once… I don’t think the entire Injustice Society has been namechecked once since this new fun began.
Regular artist Diego Olortegui isn’t around this month – maybe he’s doing a JSA Annual (Holy Manifesting, Batman!) – but the art doesn’t suffer. Fill-in fella Joey Vazquez does a cracking job, with fast-moving layouts, attractive heroes and dastardly villains. I especially like Solomon Grundy here, he’s hugely imposing. The colours of Luis Guerro emphasise the mysterious, labyrinthine nature of the baddies’ base, with glowing spaces at the end of every corridor. The font choices of Steve Wands also look great, with sharp use of colouring to help show who’s narrating which pages.
As for Cully Hamner’s cover, the looming Grundy silhouette and stippled starburst around the logo make it.
So, another good instalment – I just wish each JSA was a giant, like the Golden Age All-Star Comics, with a complete story in each issue. Just imagine…
Has Lemire always written things assuming you know the full history of every character and their powers? I have no clue who attacked Beth at all and there’s nothing on the page to help. I love the JSA but I can’t get past things like this here. That and other amateur hour story choices. Starting a story in the middle is a classic trope but not explaining a damn thing four issues in? Ignoring inconvenient hero histories to tell your story? It’s like Beth and Todd are coming right from early appearances and she never died and Todd never met the best Manhunter. And please, don’t establish Beth is totally blind and have her succeed easily at everything she tries. I feel like I’m done but I know I’ll be sucked back in. Maybe Lemire will explain everything, including why almost no one is acting in character.
LikeLiked by 2 people
So Steve, you inspired me to politely post to Jeff Lemire on Bluesky: ‘Hi, I’m buying and enjoying JSA but could you namecheck featured characters at least once per issue? A roll call would be fab, but otherwise as people become players, eg in #4 Scandal Savage isn’t named once. Dr Mid-Nite being named last time would have helped new readers’
Answer: Tumbleweed
LikeLike
I liked this issue, and Vazquez’s art. I especially liked the Beth Chapel parts; I’m glad she’s getting more of a spotlight these days.
I’m also frustrated by Lemire & editorial not identifying characters. A couple caption boxes is all it takes. I’m less frustrated by any “out of continuity” choices the team might make, because there’s barely such a thing anymore.
But I agree — this is a puzzling launch, about as new-reader-unfriendly as you can get.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Editorial these days, because they don’t have to answer to readers on the letters page, don’t seem to care about clarity.
LikeLike